Your shopping bag is empty.
FREE SHIPPING when you spend $75 or more! - see details
Store Locator

Easter Toys

Sort By
1 2 3 … 5 >
1 2 3 … 5 ►>

About Easter Toys

When it comes to Easter baskets, it’s what’s inside that counts! Give the Easter bunny a hand this year, and make sure your little one’s Easter basket is filled with all sorts of candy, activities, and toys! Store-bought, pre-made baskets are fine, but a truly memorable Easter basket is one that’s filled from scratch with a hand-picked assortment of everything kids love!

Even a single, special toy nestled inside an Easter basket can make a lasting impact on a child. The perfect gift is a memory that’ll last forever, so be sure to pick something that a child is sure to love! If you’re simply not sure what to pick, look to the hottest trends going this season for inspiration! For example, Mermaid pillows and other sequin accessories from Mermaid Pillow Company are high-quality gifts that change colors with shifting sequins and are a blast to play around with!

As far as more traditional toys go, Hatchimals are still hatching their way into kids’ hearts everywhere, and they’re just so much fun to take care of and play with! One of our favorites here at The Paper Store, though, has to be Crazy Aaron’s Thinking Putty since each tin is filled with safe, kid-friendly putty that sparkles, shines, and can even change color. Kids who find a tin of Crazy Aaron’s Thinking Putty tucked inside their Easter basket are sure to enjoy their new gift long after Easter has come and gone since it’s just so much fun to shape and mold!

No matter your choice for Easter basket stuffers, make them meaningful ones that’ll be memorable. Trust us - a great gift will stick with a child for years and years, and it might even become a treasured keepsake into adulthood and last a lifetime!

Quick Find
Customer Service
Our Company
Need Help?
  • Toll Free: (844) 480-7100 (MON-FRI 9-5PM EST)
  TODAY'S OFFERS
 
Image of loader