25% OFF ONE FULL PRICED ITEM* | Use code: XOXO | *Exclusions Apply | SHOP NOW

*Due to the storm, all stores except FL/IL will be closed Mon 1/26, In-Store Pickup Orders will be available next business day*

The Paper Store

Puzzles

Found216Results.
000827_1000684167_NoColor.jpg
Hachette Book Group

Liberty Prospect Road Book Jigsaw Puzzle (500 pc.)

$19.99
25% Off One Regularly Priced Item* Use Code XOXO
000894_1000525851_NoColor.jpg
New
Random House

Valentine's Hidden Pictures - Puzzles to Highlight

$6.99
25% Off One Regularly Priced Item* Use Code XOXO
005515_1000704118_No Color.jpg
New
EMILY LEX STUDIO

Love Sweet Love Paintable Watercolor Notecard Set

$20.00
25% Off One Regularly Priced Item* Use Code XOXO
001728_1000638767_NoColor.jpg
White Mountain Puzzles

I Love Golf Jigsaw Puzzle (1,000 pc.)

$22.99
25% Off One Regularly Priced Item* Use Code XOXO
001728_1000642596_NoColor.jpg
White Mountain Puzzles

Words of Wisdom Jigsaw Puzzle (1,000 pc.)

$22.99
25% Off One Regularly Priced Item* Use Code XOXO
000998_1000626899_NoColor.jpg
Springbok

Oceanside Sunset Jigsaw Puzzle (1,000 pc.)

$22.99
25% Off One Regularly Priced Item* Use Code XOXO
001728_1000642595_NoColor.jpg
White Mountain Puzzles

Things We Say Jigsaw Puzzle (1,000 pc.)

$22.99
25% Off One Regularly Priced Item* Use Code XOXO
001420_1000559874_NoColor.jpg
Masterpieces Puzzle Company

Hershey's Kisses Shaped Jigsaw Puzzle (500 pc.)

$16.99
25% Off One Regularly Priced Item* Use Code XOXO
001188_1000649175_NoColor.jpg
Eeboo

Axolotl 20-Piece Jigsaw Puzzle

$11.99
25% Off One Regularly Priced Item* Use Code XOXO
001728_1000601574_NoColor.jpg
White Mountain Puzzles

I Love Florida Jigsaw Puzzle (1,000 pc.)

$22.99
25% Off One Regularly Priced Item* Use Code XOXO
003931_1000691178_MultiColororPatte.jpg
Plus-Plus USA

Ocean Puzzle By Number Activity Pad

$16.99
25% Off One Regularly Priced Item* Use Code XOXO
001728_1000509192_NoColor.jpg
White Mountain Puzzles

New York, New York Jigsaw Puzzle (1,000 pc.)

$22.99
25% Off One Regularly Priced Item* Use Code XOXO
006018_1000692596_NoColor.jpg
Julias Broderie LLC

Wildflowers Kitchen Towel Embroidery Kit

$42.00
25% Off One Regularly Priced Item* Use Code XOXO
001728_1000420979_NoColor.jpg
White Mountain Puzzles

I Love Cape Cod Jigsaw Puzzle (1,000 pc.)

$22.99
25% Off One Regularly Priced Item* Use Code XOXO
005472_1000685087_NoColor.jpg
Piecework LLC

Dozen Donuts Mini Jigsaw Puzzle Collection

$38.00$19.00
000894_1000626715_NoColor.jpg
Random House

Let's Go Neon Travel Hidden Pictures Puzzles

$6.99
25% Off One Regularly Priced Item* Use Code XOXO
001420_1000559872_NoColor.jpg
Masterpieces Puzzle Company

Puzzle Roll-Up Storage Mat

$19.99
25% Off One Regularly Priced Item* Use Code XOXO
000853_1000702695_No Color.jpg
Kikkerland

Bird Punch Needle Craft Kit

$15.00
25% Off One Regularly Priced Item* Use Code XOXO
006018_1000692594_NoColor.jpg
Julias Broderie LLC

Pink Blush Bouquet Embroidery Kit

$40.00
25% Off One Regularly Priced Item* Use Code XOXO
006018_1000692595_NoColor.jpg
Julias Broderie LLC

Garden Flowers Embroidery Kit

$40.00
25% Off One Regularly Priced Item* Use Code XOXO
001728_1000553419_NoColor.jpg
White Mountain Puzzles

Best Sellers Jigsaw Puzzle (1,000 pc.)

$22.99
25% Off One Regularly Priced Item* Use Code XOXO
000853_1000702694_No Color.jpg
Kikkerland

Tulips Punch Needle Craft Kit

$15.00
25% Off One Regularly Priced Item* Use Code XOXO
006018_1000692592_NoColor.jpg
Julias Broderie LLC

Stork and Duck by the Pond Embroidery Kit

$40.00
25% Off One Regularly Priced Item* Use Code XOXO
001728_1000504466_NoColor.jpg
White Mountain Puzzles

I Love Massachusetts Jigsaw Puzzle (1,000 pc.)

$22.99
25% Off One Regularly Priced Item* Use Code XOXO
001728_1000456501_NoColor.jpg
White Mountain Puzzles

I Love New Hampshire Jigsaw Puzzle (1,000 pc)

$22.99
25% Off One Regularly Priced Item* Use Code XOXO
001420_1000686304_NoColor_ALT1(1).jpg
New
Masterpieces Puzzle Company

Garden Friends Chunky Wooden Puzzles Set (Pack of 4)

$16.99
25% Off One Regularly Priced Item* Use Code XOXO
002497_1000626989_NoColor.jpg
Outset Media

Butterfly Garden Jigsaw Puzzle (1,000 pc.)

$22.99
25% Off One Regularly Priced Item* Use Code XOXO
001420_1000686305_NoColor_ALT1(1).jpg
Masterpieces Puzzle Company

Dinosaurs Chunky Wood Puzzles (Pack of 4)

$16.99
25% Off One Regularly Priced Item* Use Code XOXO
000853_1000702699_No Color.jpg
Kikkerland

Ladybug Mini Cross Stitch Embroidery Kit

$9.00
25% Off One Regularly Priced Item* Use Code XOXO
000827_1000701512_No Color.jpg
New
Hachette Book Group

Cottagecore Cross-Stitch Kit

$10.95
25% Off One Regularly Priced Item* Use Code XOXO
000853_1000702700_No Color.jpg
Kikkerland

Burger Mini Cross Stitch Embroidery Kit

$9.00
25% Off One Regularly Priced Item* Use Code XOXO
000853_1000702701_No Color.jpg
New
Kikkerland

Flowers Mini Cross Stitch Embroidery Kit

$9.00
25% Off One Regularly Priced Item* Use Code XOXO
000853_1000702696_No Color.jpg
New
Kikkerland

Cat Punch Needle Craft Kit

$15.00
25% Off One Regularly Priced Item* Use Code XOXO
000827_1000684181_NoColor.jpg
Hachette Book Group

Michael Storrings A Sunny Day in Palm Beach Jigsaw Puzzle (1,000 pc.)

$17.99
25% Off One Regularly Priced Item* Use Code XOXO
001728_1000408285_NoColor.jpg
White Mountain Puzzles

Things I Ate As A Kid 1000 Piece Puzzle

$22.99
25% Off One Regularly Priced Item* Use Code XOXO
000827_1000684188_NoColor.jpg
Hachette Book Group

Anne Bentley Lounge Dogs Jigsaw Puzzle (500 pc.)

$14.99
25% Off One Regularly Priced Item* Use Code XOXO
001728_1000699301_NoColor.jpg
White Mountain Puzzles

Gone Skiing Jigsaw Puzzle (1,000 pc.)

$22.99
25% Off One Regularly Priced Item* Use Code XOXO
001728_1000662155_NoColor.jpg
White Mountain Puzzles

Movie Snacks Jigsaw Puzzle (1,000 pc.)

$22.99
25% Off One Regularly Priced Item* Use Code XOXO
001728_1000678411_NoColor.jpg
White Mountain Puzzles

Lake Retreat Jigsaw Puzzle (1,000 pc.)

$22.99
25% Off One Regularly Priced Item* Use Code XOXO
001728_1000382671_NoColor.jpg
White Mountain Puzzles

I Love New England Jigsaw Puzzle (1,000 pc)

$22.99
25% Off One Regularly Priced Item* Use Code XOXO
005302_1000667743_NoColor.jpg
West Design Products Limited

Cacti 5-Inch Embroidery Kit

$8.99
25% Off One Regularly Priced Item* Use Code XOXO
001728_1000662156_NoColor.jpg
White Mountain Puzzles

I Love Illinois Jigsaw Puzzle (1,000 pc.)

$22.99
25% Off One Regularly Priced Item* Use Code XOXO
001728_1000456502_NoColor.jpg
White Mountain Puzzles

I Love Maine Jigsaw Puzzle (1,000 pc)

$22.99
25% Off One Regularly Priced Item* Use Code XOXO
000998_1000616293_NoColor.jpg
Springbok

Smoothie Bowls Jigsaw Puzzle (1,000 pc.)

$22.99
25% Off One Regularly Priced Item* Use Code XOXO
000998_1000641195_NoColor.jpg
Springbok

Beautiful Blossoms Jigsaw Puzzle (500 pc.)

$18.99
25% Off One Regularly Priced Item* Use Code XOXO
001728_1000522942_NoColor.jpg
White Mountain Puzzles

Best Places in America Jigsaw Puzzle (1,000 pc)

$22.99
25% Off One Regularly Priced Item* Use Code XOXO
001728_1000638765_NoColor.jpg
White Mountain Puzzles

I Love Hockey Jigsaw Puzzle (1,000 pc.)

$22.99
25% Off One Regularly Priced Item* Use Code XOXO
002497_1000686458_NoColor.jpg
Outset Media

Create Your Own Floor Puzzle

$18.99
25% Off One Regularly Priced Item* Use Code XOXO