Plush

Few makers of plush toys are more beloved than Ty, Inc.! Whether you’re looking for a classic-style Beanie Baby or one of their new Beanie Boos or Flippables stuffed animals, you’re sure to find a terrifically cuddly pal. From their biggest animals all the way down to their super-small Teeny Tys, there are plenty of colorful, adorable options. And if you’d prefer to decorate your desk, car, or home with your favorite Jedi Knight, superhero, or Disney princess, Hallmark’s itty bittys line offers character to spare. They even have tiny plush toys based on star athletes!

From kitties and cows to koalas and donkeys, Jellycat offers animal friends of all stripes your littlest ones will love to cuddle up with. Made with softness and safety in mind, they make exceptional gifts for baby showers and first birthdays! Plus, if you want a sweet stuffed animal made with quality and realistic style in mind, our offerings from brands like Douglas and Aurora World are exceptional toys suitable for play and display. With plenty of holiday-themed options to choose from, it’s easy to find the perfect stocking stuffer or Easter basket toy.

Whatever your needs, a plush toy from The Paper Store is sure to delight. From the squishy, pillow-like softness of the super-cute animals in the Squishmallows squad to collectible plush toys based on Pinkfong’s global hit song “Baby Shark,” there are so many possibilities for you and your little ones to enjoy. Simply browse today - it’s never been easier to make a new friend!