FREE SHIPPING on orders $75+ | IN A RUSH? Buy online, pick up in-store in 2 hours
The Paper Store

Valentine's Day Jewelry

Found333Results.
001062_1000427672_NoColor.jpg
Cape Cod Jewelry

Reverse Two-Tone Single Ball Bracelet

$345.00
001062_1000602352_NoColor.jpg
Cape Cod Jewelry

Double Bead Bracelet in Two-Tone

$625.00
001062_1000021643_NoColor_V2.jpg
Cape Cod Jewelry

Medium Two-Tone Collection Earrings

$450.00
001062_1000677541_NoColor.jpg
Cape Cod Jewelry

Triple Ball Bangle Bracelet in Sterling Silver

$350.00
001157_1000709135_Blush.jpg
New
Demdaco

Love You Pink Bear Plush with Bracelet

$21.00
005171_1000705133_Multicolor.tif
New
Stories Unknown

Heart Pendant Paracord Necklace in Red and Gold

$18.00
005171_1000705134_Multicolor.tif
New
Stories Unknown

Heart Pendant Paracord Necklace in Navy and Gold

$18.00
005171_1000705136_Multicolor.tif
New
Stories Unknown

Heart Charm Paracord Bracelet in Red and Gold

$16.00
005171_1000705137_Multicolor.tif
New
Stories Unknown

Heart Charm Paracord Bracelet in Black and Silver

$16.00
005171_1000705135_Multicolor.tif
New
Stories Unknown

Heart Pendant Paracord Necklace in Black and Silver

$18.00
006052_1000709530_Silver.jpg
New
My Italian Bracelet

Family Heart Charm in Silver

$8.00
Buy 4 Charms Get 1 Free
006052_1000709545_Silver.jpg
New
My Italian Bracelet

I Love You Charm in Silver

$8.00
Buy 4 Charms Get 1 Free
006052_1000709542_Gold.jpg
New
My Italian Bracelet

I Love You Heart Dangling Charm in Gold

$8.00
Buy 4 Charms Get 1 Free
005024_1000707917_Gold.jpg
New
&LIVY

Love You More POSY Wire Bracelet in Gold

$28.00
005024_1000707918_Silver.jpg
New
&LIVY

Love You More POSY Wire Bracelet in Silver

$28.00
006052_1000709531_Gold.jpg
New
My Italian Bracelet

Mom Heart Charm in Gold

$8.00
Buy 4 Charms Get 1 Free
006052_1000709532_Silver.jpg
New
My Italian Bracelet

Mom Heart Charm in Silver

$8.00
Buy 4 Charms Get 1 Free
005148_1000701492_Gold.jpg
New
A Littles & Co

Mother's Day A Little "Love You Mom" Necklace in Gold

$28.00
005171_1000705138_Multicolor.tif
New
Stories Unknown

Heart Charm Paracord Bracelet in Navy and Gold

$16.00
002968_1000700732_Silver.tif
New
mia & tess

Multicolor Beaded Heart Pendant Necklace in Silver

$20.00
001157_1000707876_No Color.jpg
New
Giving

Love You Giving Bear with Heart Bracelet

$21.00
003717_1000709523_MultiColororPatte.jpg
New
Little Words Project

Love You Beaded Letter Bracelet

$25.00
005148_1000701483_Gold.jpg
New
A Littles & Co

Mother's Day A Little "Love You Mom" Bracelet in Gold

$28.00
002968_1000700731_Gold.tif
New
mia & tess

Multicolor Beaded Heart Pendant Necklace in Gold

$20.00
005220_1000654626_NoColor.jpg
New
kate spade new york

Pearl Heart Pendant Necklace in Gold

$58.00
004001_1000675143_NoColor_ALT1.tif
Exclusively Ours
mia & tess

CZ Heart Long Pendant Necklace in Gold

$24.99
003476_1000656459_NoColor.jpg
Kendra Scott

Heart Pendant Necklace in White Diamonds

$450.00
001365_1000638387_NoColor.jpg
Heritage by Kit Heath

Entwined Heart with Cubic Zirconia Stud Earrings

$34.00
001579_1000559127_NoColor.jpg
Silver Forest

Two-Tone Layered Heart Drop Earrings

$19.00
006052_1000695489_MultiColororPatte.jpg
My Italian Bracelet

Red Heart Eye Charm in Silver

$8.00
Buy 4 Charms Get 1 Free
003280_1000653431_NoColor.jpg
Dune Jewelry

Heart Necklace with Cape Cod Sand and Turquoise in Silver

$59.00
005169_1000673345_NoColor.jpg
Electric Picks

Love Potion Crystal Heart Necklace in Gold

$78.00
004667_1000692730_Silver.jpg
Stia Jewelry

Crystal Heart Prong Pendant Necklace in Silver

$45.00
003733_1000699787_MultiColororPatte.jpg
Canvas Style

Enamel Heart Charm in Red

$15.00
003733_1000699788_MultiColororPatte.jpg
Canvas Style

Celestial Enamel Heart Charm in Black

$15.00
005425_1000680380_NoColor.jpg
Ana Luisa

Daryl Heart Earrings in Gold

$70.00
004667_1000692868_Gold.jpg
Swish

Heart of Gold Charm Bracelet in Gold

$25.00
003465_1000675285_NoColor.tif
Exclusively Ours
mia & tess

Puffy Heart Pearl Stretch Bracelet in Silver

$16.99
005169_1000673355_NoColor.jpg
Electric Picks

Sweetheart Bracelet in Gold

$88.00
002052_1000650024_NoColor.jpg
Layers

Heart of Gold CZ Adjustable Necklace in Gold

$19.99
Layers Necklaces 2 for $30
001044_1000647779_NoColor.jpg
Periwinkle by Barlow

Etched Filigree Heart Hoop Earrings in Silver

$14.99
003768_1000680167_NoColor.jpg
Gorjana

Heart Statement Charm in Gold

$50.00
006052_1000695504_MultiColororPatte.jpg
My Italian Bracelet

Heart with Paw Prints Charm in Silver

$8.00
Buy 4 Charms Get 1 Free
004545_1000659564_NoColor.jpg
H.E.L.P. by T. Jazelle

Career Girl Charity Bracelet: Purple Selenite with Hearts Charity Stacker

$24.99
004545_1000654593_NoColor.jpg
Tiffany Jazelle

Exclusive Friendship Heart Pendant Necklace in Silver

$65.00
003579_1000687336_NoColor.tif
Exclusively Ours
mia & tess

Abalone Heart Pendant Necklace in Silver

$14.99
002055_1000698810_Gold.jpg
Spartina 449

Radiant Heart Sea La Vie Necklace in Gold

$44.00
006052_1000699434_MultiColororPatte.jpg
My Italian Bracelet

CZ Heart Charm in Silver

$8.00
Buy 4 Charms Get 1 Free