FREE SHIPPING on orders $75+ | IN A RUSH? Buy online, pick up in-store in 2 hours
The Paper Store

Valentine's Day Jewelry

Found290Results.
001062_1000427672_NoColor.jpg
Cape Cod Jewelry

Reverse Two-Tone Single Ball Bracelet

$275.00
001062_1000602352_NoColor.jpg
Cape Cod Jewelry

Double Bead Bracelet in Two-Tone

$450.00
001062_1000021652_NoColor_v1.jpg
Cape Cod Jewelry

Smooth Single Pendant Necklace (16 Chain)

$275.00
001062_1000021643_NoColor_V2.jpg
Cape Cod Jewelry

Medium Two-Tone Collection Earrings

$300.00
001062_1000021634_NoColor_v1.jpg
Cape Cod Jewelry

Swirl Gold Single Bracelet - Size 6.5

$325.00
001062_1000677541_NoColor.jpg
Cape Cod Jewelry

Triple Ball Bangle Bracelet in Sterling Silver

$210.00
005148_1000701407_Gold.jpg
New
A Littles & Co

A Little Charmed Moments "Love You to the Moon and Back" Bracelet in Silver, Gold, and Rose Gold

$28.00
005148_1000701403_Silver.jpg
New
A Littles & Co

A Little "Thank You From the Bottom of My Heart" Bracelet in Silver

$25.00
005148_1000701419_Gold.jpg
New
A Littles & Co

Sparkle Confetti A Little "Heart of Gold" Bracelet in Silver and Gold

$30.00
005148_1000701428_Gold.jpg
New
A Littles & Co

A Little "Love You With All My Heart" Bracelet in Gold

$35.00
003365_1000702031_Multicolor.tif
New
mia & tess

Hearts Multi Charm Necklace in Gold

$20.00
003365_1000702032_Multicolor.tif
New
mia & tess

Hearts Multi Charm Necklace in Silver

$20.00
003717_1000704784_MultiColororPatte.jpg
New
Little Words Project

Love You More Beaded Letter Bracelet

$25.00
001044_1000704885_MultiColororPatte.jpg
New
Periwinkle by Barlow

Shiny Heart Drop Earrings in Silver

$14.99
001044_1000704886_MultiColororPatte.jpg
New
Periwinkle by Barlow

Shiny Heart Drop Earrings in Gold

$14.99
001044_1000704893_MultiColororPatte.jpg
New
Periwinkle by Barlow

Textured Double Heart Drop Earrings in Two-Tone

$14.99
001044_1000704900_MultiColororPatte.jpg
New
Periwinkle by Barlow

Heart Stations Chain Bracelet in Silver

$18.99
001044_1000704913_MultiColororPatte.jpg
New
Periwinkle by Barlow

Shiny Heart Pendant Necklace in Gold

$16.99
001044_1000704918_MultiColororPatte.jpg
New
Periwinkle by Barlow

Double Heart Brooch Pin in Gold

$18.99
001044_1000704901_MultiColororPatte.jpg
New
Periwinkle by Barlow

Heart Charm Toggle Bracelet in Gold

$18.99
006093_1000705144_Multicolor.tif
New
Stories Unknown

Gold Heart Braided Cord Necklace in Multi Pink

$16.00
001044_1000704963_MultiColororPatte.jpg
New
Periwinkle by Barlow

Hearts Station Chain Anklet in Silver

$16.99
003767_1000698334_MultiColororPatte.jpg
New
Pura Vida Jewelry

Lydia Heart Charm Bracelet in Red and Gold

$12.00
006084_1000700721_Brown.tif
New
mia & tess

Natural Heart Pendant Necklace in Gold

$14.00
006084_1000700720_LtBlue.tif
New
mia & tess

Light Blue Heart Pendant Necklace in Silver

$14.00
005524_1000690543_Gold.jpg
Karma and Luck

Devoted to Love Evil Eye Heart Charm Red String Bracelet

$100.00
006052_1000695503_MultiColororPatte.jpg
My Italian Bracelet

Clear Heart Charm in Silver

$8.00
Buy 4 Charms Get 1 Free
004667_1000692799_Gold.jpg
Isla

Bursting Heart Pendant Necklace in Gold

$25.00
006052_1000699434_MultiColororPatte.jpg
My Italian Bracelet

CZ Heart Charm in Silver

$8.00
Buy 4 Charms Get 1 Free
005010_1000661902_NoColor.jpg
National Chain Company

.25CT Heart Pendant Diamond Necklace in 14K White Gold

$700.00
005303_1000665059_NoColor.jpg
Satya Jewelry / Sube Inc

Heart Chakra Charm in Gold

$25.00
002594_1000665242_NoColor.jpg
Ocean

Exclusive Heart and Star Light Sapphire Crystal Necklace in Silver

$150.00
005148_1000672812_NoColor.jpg
A Littles & Co

Kids' From the Heart Gift Box First Holy Communion Bracelet in Silver

$25.00
006052_1000695489_MultiColororPatte.jpg
My Italian Bracelet

Red Heart Eye Charm in Silver

$8.00
Buy 4 Charms Get 1 Free
003465_1000675311_NoColor.tif
Oz Jewerly

Hearts Multi Charm Chain Necklace in Gold

$19.99
005220_1000654625_NoColor.jpg
kate spade new york

My Love Pearl Heart Stud Earrings in Gold

$48.00
005024_1000689494_Silver.jpg
&LIVY

Fire-Hearted Charm in Silver

$28.00
004545_1000637163_NoColor.jpg
Tiffany Jazelle

Exclusive Heart of Friendship Charm Bracelet with Blue Aquamarine Beads

$59.99
003485_1000696091_Silver.jpg
Melinda Maria Designs

Julian XL Heart Cuban Chain Bracelet in Silver

$110.00
003280_1000675631_NoColor_v1.jpg
Dune Jewelry

Explorer Heart Drop Earrings with Pink 4Ocean Plastic

$59.00
004667_1000663085_NoColor.jpg
Stia Jewelry

Sacred Heart Crystal Pendant Necklace in Gold

$49.00
005524_1000690565_Gold.jpg
Karma and Luck

Grounded in Love Black Onyx Heart Diamond Evil Eye Necklace in Gold

$185.00
005024_1000698305_Silver.jpg
&LIVY

Mini Heart Charm in Silver

$24.00
005024_1000689493_Gold.jpg
&LIVY

Fire-Hearted Charm

$28.00
005024_1000689503_Gold.jpg
&LIVY

Heart Love Charm

$18.00
006052_1000695505_MultiColororPatte.jpg
My Italian Bracelet

I Love You Charm in Silver

$8.00
Buy 4 Charms Get 1 Free
004667_1000692714_Gold.jpg
Stia Jewelry

Pink Beaded Heart Detail Bracelet in Gold

$45.00
005303_1000684776_NoColor.jpg
Satya Jewelry / Sube Inc

Infinitely Loved Heart Necklace

$110.00