Crazy Aaron’s Thinking Putty & Gifts

Consider us your Squishy Headquarters! | New Squishies Keep Popping Up | Shop Now

Educators & Healthcare Workers Save 10% off In-Store!

FREE Exclusive Cape Cod Jewelry Box with Cape Cod Jewelry purchase of $250+ | Online Only | Shop Now

My Account

Search In-Store Only

Consider us your Squishy Headquarters! | New Squishies Keep Popping Up | Shop Now

Educators & Healthcare Workers Save 10% off In-Store!

FREE Exclusive Cape Cod Jewelry Box with Cape Cod Jewelry purchase of $250+ | Online Only | Shop Now

Crazy Aaron

Triceratops Mini Thinking Putty

Shark Mini Thinking Putty

Mix Your Own GRWM Thinking Putty

Mix Your Own Fruity Smoothy Thinking Putty

Mermaid Tale Glow in the Dark Thinking Putty

Amazing Axolotl Thinking Putty

Mini Color Change K-Pop Thinking Putty

Mini Fairy Sprinkles Thinking Putty

Mini Funky Fidget Thinking Putty

Mini Daydream Thinking Putty

Intergalactic Trendsetters Thinking Putty

Goodnight Cactus Hypercolor Thinking Putty

Pistachio Mini Thinking Putty

Country Pop Mini Thinking Putty

Blobfish Mini Thinking Putty

Mini Avocado Thinking Putty

Cotton Candy Mini Color Change Thinking Putty

Pickleball Mini Thinking Putty

Mini SCENTsory Strawberry Shortcake Thinking Putty

Scoopberry Scentsory Thinking Putty

Mini Mystic Crystal Thinking Putty

Mini Gummy Grizzly K-Pop Thinking Putty

Mini SCENTsory Orange Blossom Thinking Putty

Mini SCENTsory Blueberry Muffin Thinking Putty

Mini Rock N' Roll Thinking Putty

Mini Starfish Thinking Putty

Consider us your Squishy Headquarters! | New Squishies Keep Popping Up | Shop Now

Educators & Healthcare Workers Save 10% off In-Store!

FREE Exclusive Cape Cod Jewelry Box with Cape Cod Jewelry purchase of $250+ | Online Only | Shop Now

Crazy Aaron

Pickup & Shipping

Type

Color

Price

Triceratops Mini Thinking Putty

Shark Mini Thinking Putty

Mix Your Own GRWM Thinking Putty

Mix Your Own Fruity Smoothy Thinking Putty

Mermaid Tale Glow in the Dark Thinking Putty

Amazing Axolotl Thinking Putty

Mini Color Change K-Pop Thinking Putty

Mini Fairy Sprinkles Thinking Putty

Mini Funky Fidget Thinking Putty

Mini Daydream Thinking Putty

Intergalactic Trendsetters Thinking Putty

Goodnight Cactus Hypercolor Thinking Putty

Pistachio Mini Thinking Putty

Country Pop Mini Thinking Putty

Blobfish Mini Thinking Putty

Mini Avocado Thinking Putty

Cotton Candy Mini Color Change Thinking Putty

Pickleball Mini Thinking Putty

Mini SCENTsory Strawberry Shortcake Thinking Putty

Scoopberry Scentsory Thinking Putty

Mini Mystic Crystal Thinking Putty

Mini Gummy Grizzly K-Pop Thinking Putty

Mini SCENTsory Orange Blossom Thinking Putty

Mini SCENTsory Blueberry Muffin Thinking Putty

Mini Rock N' Roll Thinking Putty

Mini Starfish Thinking Putty