SALE ON SALE | EXTRA 20% OFF SALE & CLEARANCE* | *Exclusions Apply
The Paper Store

Valentine's Day Jewelry

Found304Results.
002055_1000698810_Gold.jpg
New
Spartina 449

Radiant Heart Sea La Vie Necklace in Gold

$44.00
002055_1000698811_Silver.jpg
New
Spartina 449

Radiant Heart Sea La Vie Necklace in Silver

$44.00
004001_1000675132_NoColor.tif
Exclusively Ours
Mia & Tess

Pearl and Chain Heart Pendant Necklace in Gold

$29.99
005169_1000673345_NoColor.jpg
Electric Picks

Love Potion Crystal Heart Necklace in Gold

$78.00
006052_1000695503_MultiColororPatte.jpg
My Italian Bracelet

Clear Heart Charm in Silver

$8.00
Buy 4 Charms Get 1 Free
003465_1000675285_NoColor.tif
Exclusively Ours
Mia & Tess

Puffy Heart Pearl Stretch Bracelet in Silver

$16.99
004667_1000638127_NoColor.jpg
Stia Jewelry

It Fits! Bezel Heart CZ Droplet Ring in Silver

$25.00
005169_1000673355_NoColor.jpg
Electric Picks

Sweetheart Bracelet in Gold

$88.00
004001_1000675143_NoColor_ALT1.tif
Exclusively Ours
Mia & Tess

CZ Heart Long Pendant Necklace in Gold

$24.99
002055_1000672369_NoColor_v1.jpg
Spartina 449

Mama Heart Sea La Vie Necklace in Silver

$44.00
005148_1000677749_NoColor.jpg
A Littles & Co

Small Soul Sister Blue Heart Charm in Gold

$12.00
006052_1000695489_MultiColororPatte.jpg
My Italian Bracelet

Red Heart Eye Charm in Silver

$8.00
Buy 4 Charms Get 1 Free
005148_1000677775_NoColor.jpg
A Littles & Co

Large Follow Your Heart Compass Charm in Gold

$20.00
004545_1000637163_NoColor.jpg
Tiffany Jazelle

Exclusive Heart of Friendship Charm Bracelet with Blue Aquamarine Beads

$59.99
004001_1000675161_NoColor.tif
Exclusively Ours
Mia & Tess

Heart and Teal Stone Charm Bracelet in Gold

$29.99
005171_1000688033_NoColor.tif
Exclusively Ours
Uncharted Threads

Repeating Heart Band Ring in Gold Size 8

$14.99
005148_1000672812_NoColor.jpg
A Littles & Co

Kids' From the Heart Gift Box First Holy Communion Bracelet in Silver

$25.00
003280_1000653431_NoColor.jpg
Dune Jewelry

Heart Necklace with Cape Cod Sand and Turquoise in Silver

$59.00
005010_1000661902_NoColor.jpg
National Chain Company

.25CT Heart Pendant Diamond Necklace in 14K White Gold

$700.00
005524_1000690585_Gold.jpg
Karma and Luck

Spiritual Delight Heart Black Enamel Diamond Ring in Gold

$100.00
006052_1000695504_MultiColororPatte.jpg
My Italian Bracelet

Heart with Paw Prints Charm in Silver

$8.00
Buy 4 Charms Get 1 Free
004667_1000626064_NoColor.jpg
Stia Jewelry

Mom Heart Bangle Bracelet

$45.00
004001_1000675120_NoColor.tif
Exclusively Ours
Mia & Tess

Spike Border Heart Pendant Necklace

$24.99
005425_1000694816_Gold.jpg
Ana Luisa

Ellery Heart Necklace in Two-Tone

$75.00
005303_1000684786_NoColor.jpg
Satya Jewelry / Sube Inc

Healing Heart Red Onyx Heart Bracelet

$110.00
005010_1000661901_NoColor.jpg
National Chain Company

.25CT Heart Pendant Diamond Necklace in 14K Yellow Gold

$700.00
004667_1000663086_NoColor.jpg
Stia Jewelry

Sacred Heart Crystal Pendant Necklace in Silver

$49.00
002055_1000667888_NoColor.jpg
Spartina 449

Limelight Heart Bracelet in Gold

$42.00
005148_1000677774_NoColor.jpg
A Littles & Co

Large Grateful Heart Charm in Gold

$20.00
006052_1000699444_MultiColororPatte.jpg
My Italian Bracelet

Love You to the Moon and Back Charm in Two-Tone

$8.00
Buy 4 Charms Get 1 Free
005148_1000677726_NoColor.jpg
A Littles & Co

Heart Shaped Charm Lock

$12.00
005303_1000684789_NoColor.jpg
Satya Jewelry / Sube Inc

Healing Heart Red Onyx Heart Necklace

$180.00
001560_1000673913_NoColor.jpg
Creative Brands

PS I Love You Stud Earrings and Ring Dish Set

$25.00
005148_1000677755_NoColor.jpg
A Littles & Co

Medium Pavé Love Heart Charm in Silver

$15.00
004545_1000654593_NoColor.jpg
Tiffany Jazelle

Exclusive Friendship Heart Pendant Necklace in Silver

$59.99
006052_1000699434_MultiColororPatte.jpg
My Italian Bracelet

CZ Heart Charm in Silver

$8.00
Buy 4 Charms Get 1 Free
003579_1000687336_NoColor.tif
Exclusively Ours
Mia & Tess

Abalone Heart Pendant Necklace in Silver

$14.99
006052_1000695491_MultiColororPatte.jpg
My Italian Bracelet

Dangling Pink Heart Charm in Silver

$8.00
Buy 4 Charms Get 1 Free
006052_1000695497_MultiColororPatte.jpg
My Italian Bracelet

Golden Hearts Charm in Silver

$8.00
Buy 4 Charms Get 1 Free
005425_1000694808_Gold.jpg
Ana Luisa

Leia Heart Ring in Gold - Size 7

$65.00
004927_1000673894_NoColor.jpg
Colby Davis Of Boston

Sterling Silver Medium Heart Pendant in Lavender

$150.00
003476_1000663068_NoColor.jpg
Kendra Scott

Framed Ari Heart Gold Short Pendant Necklace in Light Pink Drusy

$70.00
004545_1000652660_NoColor.jpg
Tiffany Jazelle

Madagascar Quartz Gemstone Bracelet with Mom Heart Charm

$59.99
005148_1000677789_NoColor.jpg
A Littles & Co

Large Be Kind Long Heart Charm in Gold

$20.00
005169_1000673348_NoColor.jpg
Electric Picks

Sweetheart Necklace in Gold

$108.00
005148_1000677780_NoColor.jpg
A Littles & Co

Large Be Kind Long Heart Charm in Silver

$20.00
005253_1000663045_NoColor.jpg
Ella Stein

Small Heart Pendant Necklace in Gold

$100.00
005148_1000672837_NoColor.jpg
A Littles & Co

Mother's Day A Little "Love You To The Moon And Back Mom" Bracelet in Gold

$25.00